Write a short note on discuss the role of eyewitness and elucidate the procedure to assess eyewitness.
Write a short note on discuss the role of eyewitness and elucidate the procedure to assess eyewitness.
Share
Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
Eyewitness testimony plays a critical role in the criminal justice system, often serving as a primary source of evidence in criminal investigations and trials. However, eyewitness testimony is subject to various factors that can influence its accuracy and reliability, including memory distortion, perception biases, suggestion, and stress. Therefore, it is essential to carefully assess the reliability of eyewitness testimony to ensure its validity in court proceedings.
The procedure to assess eyewitness testimony typically involves several key steps:
Interviewing the Eyewitness: The first step is to conduct a structured interview with the eyewitness to elicit detailed information about the event they observed. The interviewer should use open-ended questions and avoid leading or suggestive techniques that may inadvertently influence the eyewitness's memory or perception.
Documenting the Eyewitness Account: The eyewitness's account should be documented in writing or through audio/video recording to preserve the details of their recollection. This documentation serves as a record of the eyewitness's statement and can be used for further analysis and comparison.
Assessing Memory Accuracy: Psychologists may use various techniques to assess the accuracy of the eyewitness's memory, such as cognitive interviews, lineup procedures, and memory retrieval tests. Cognitive interviews involve using specific techniques, such as free recall, guided recall, and context reinstatement, to enhance the eyewitness's memory recall and minimize memory distortion.
Conducting Lineup Procedures: Lineup procedures are used to identify suspects or perpetrators based on the eyewitness's memory of the event. Sequential lineup procedures, where each lineup member is presented individually, are generally considered more reliable than simultaneous lineup procedures, where all lineup members are presented together. Additionally, double-blind administration, where the lineup administrator and eyewitness are unaware of the suspect's identity, helps prevent unintentional cues or biases.
Evaluating Confidence and Certainty: Eyewitness confidence and certainty in their identification should be assessed to gauge the reliability of their testimony. High levels of confidence do not necessarily correlate with accuracy, as witnesses may be confident in their identification even when incorrect. Therefore, it is crucial to consider other factors, such as the consistency of the eyewitness's statement and the presence of corroborating evidence.
Documenting External Influences: Any external influences or suggestive techniques used during the assessment process should be documented to ensure transparency and integrity in the evaluation of eyewitness testimony. This includes documenting any leading questions, suggestive lineup procedures, or other factors that may have influenced the eyewitness's memory or identification.
Overall, assessing eyewitness testimony requires careful consideration of various factors, including memory accuracy, lineup procedures, confidence levels, and external influences. By following structured procedures and using validated techniques, psychologists can help ensure the reliability and validity of eyewitness testimony in criminal investigations and court proceedings.