Write a short note within on write the conversion, obversion and contraposition of the following propositions : ‘‘Some philosophers are not writers.’’
Write a short note within on write the conversion, obversion and contraposition of the following propositions : ‘‘Some philosophers are not writers.’’
Share
Conversion, Obversion, and Contraposition of the Proposition "Some philosophers are not writers."
Conversion:
Conversion involves interchanging the subject and predicate terms of a proposition while maintaining the quality of the proposition. However, it's essential to recognize that conversion is not always straightforward for particular propositions.
Original Proposition: "Some philosophers are not writers."
The subject term is "philosophers," and the predicate term is "writers." In this particular proposition, the conversion will result in a proposition that might not accurately reflect the original statement due to its particular nature.
Conversion by Limitation: "Some writers are not philosophers."
This conversion by limitation is valid and retains the particular nature of the original proposition. It suggests that there exists at least one writer who is not a philosopher without making a universal claim about all writers.
Obversion:
Obversion involves changing the quality of a proposition and replacing the predicate term with its complement while negating the proposition's verb.
Original Proposition: "Some philosophers are not writers."
Obversion: "Some philosophers are non-writers."
In this obversion, the original predicate term "writers" is replaced with its complement "non-writers," and the verb "are" is negated. This reformulated proposition retains the particular nature of the original statement.
Contraposition:
Contraposition involves both converting and obverting a proposition. First, the original proposition is converted, and then the resulting proposition is obverted.
Original Proposition: "Some philosophers are not writers."
Contraposition: "Some non-writers are not philosophers."
In contraposition, the original proposition is converted by limitation to "Some writers are not philosophers," and then it is obverted to "Some non-writers are not philosophers." This formulation maintains the particular quality of the original proposition.
In summary, the conversion, obversion, and contraposition of the proposition "Some philosophers are not writers" offer alternative formulations while preserving the original statement's meaning and quality. These logical transformations provide insights into the relationships between different terms within the proposition.